Wednesday, March 9, 2011

Homemade Strawberry-Flavored Carp Bait

A fresh batch of carp bait.

I've never been much of a trout fisherman. I'm not sure why that is, but for some reason I don't find them all that appealing. I know part of this has to do with my ineptitude at catching them in my younger years, but even now that I've had a few good outings and have even caught some decent-sized fish, I'd still rather for fish for something else.

Anything else, except sunfish.

This time of year, most New Jersey anglers are counting down the days until the opening of trout season. I, on the other hand, have decided that I'm going to spend most of my time this early-spring trying to catch some of the biggest fish that swim in the freshwater of the Garden State.


For some reason, carp are not sought-after by an abundance of fisherman. Part of this is probably because they are not deemed table-worthy and part of this is probably because a lot of people think of them as nasty, dirty, bottom-dwelling fish. That part is true I guess, but they also get really really big, and that makes me want to catch them.

Since carp are herbivores, commonly used baits such as worms and shiners have very limited success. Traditional carp baits include corn and dough-balls made from bread or bagels. These often-hefty fish have developed a sophisticated palate and quite a sweet tooth, which is why many anglers flavor their baits with anise, vanilla extract and syrup. Furthermore, because some anglers like to go above and beyond the call of duty, one will find no shortage of "carp bait recipes" online or in books.

Now, although I have had some success catching carp, I have yet to find a bait that I truly love. Corn stays on the hook great, but for all the times that I've used it, I've only caught a handful of fish. Dough-balls made from Wonder Bread seem to work better than corn, but they can often fall off the hook.

Since I'm planning on spending a lot of time carp fishing over the next couple months, I figured I was going to need a better bait, and I think I've found one.

Strawberry Flavored Carp Bait

-Mix one cup of cornmeal with two cups of flour and set aside.
-Boil one pint of water then bring water down to a simmer.
-Add one small package of Strawberry Jello, one tablespoon of sugar and one tablespoon of vanilla, stirring constantly.
-Slowly add flour/cornmeal mixture until all liquid is absorbed and continue working the blob for 2 minutes.
-Remove from heat, roll into a lump, wrap in foil and refrigerate, not freeze until ready to use.

I tried this recipe out the day after I made it. It stayed on the hook incredibly well, but it's going to need a few more field tests before I can report on how well it works. The water temps still need to be a little warmer, but I did get one bite. How many fish this stuff will catch remains to be seen.

Next Up: Fishing with Niles and Lido this weekend. Most likely on Round Valley.


  1. I used this years ago and caught so many carp I filled the freezer.

  2. Worked for me caught one and missed one and one really huge one pulled the hook out of it mouth because I had my drag to tight. Easy to make I line my hook with sweet corn soaked in strawberry jello also.